Colorado Judge Strikes Down Video Editing Services
discount valium
propecia cheap
buy acomplia cheap
cheapest diazepam prices
cheapest valium prices
discount accutane
pharmacy tramadol
cheap phentermine
online diazepam
prozac online
discount zithromax
where to buy alprazolam
cheap cialis
xanax prescription
buy cheap clomid online
phentermine pharmacy
generic tramadol
valium generic
cheap cialis online
order plavix
zoloft discount
prozac online stores
buy propecia without prescription
propecia pills
online tramadol
xanax sale
nexium without prescription
cialis online
xanax generic
buy generic lorazepam
cheap alprazolam online
cheap generic zoloft
lowest price cialis
bactrim no prescription
valium for sale
buy acomplia
pharmacy valium
buy propecia
pharmacy zoloft
synthroid prescription
cheap generic viagra
levitra online
where to buy lorazepam
valium pills
cheapest doxycycline
pharmacy prozac
where to buy prozac
buy viagra
cheap nexium online
zithromax online
buy prozac online
online bactrim
where to buy flagyl
buy zoloft cheap
cheap alprazolam
alprazolam online stores
order lorazepam online
purchase zoloft online
plavix pharmacy
soma discount
cheap lorazepam
soma prices
lowest price bactrim
valium online stores
purchase propecia online
buy generic diazepam
prozac for sale
lasix online cheap
acomplia for sale
order accutane
order doxycycline
cheap tramadol
purchase accutane online
synthroid prices
cheap diazepam tablets
lasix cheap
order diazepam online
flagyl no prescription
discount synthroid
lowest price acomplia
discount prozac
cialis no prescription
pharmacy nexium
where to buy levitra
alprazolam without prescription
plavix online
lowest price flagyl
buy lorazepam without prescription
lorazepam sale
lasix
cheap clomid
bactrim cheap
buy generic zithromax
cheapest zithromax
cheapest lorazepam prices
lorazepam without a prescription
price of diazepam
buy cialis cheap
cheap generic doxycycline
soma prescription
purchase alprazolam online
buy generic cialis
doxycycline cheap
tramadol prices
cheap clomid online
prozac pharmacy
cheap levitra tablets
online levitra
cheapest plavix prices
flagyl without a prescription
cheapest levitra prices
online soma
buy plavix
propecia
levitra discount
xanax pharmacy
buy cheap acomplia
buy cheap cialis online
cheap plavix online
buy accutane without prescription
buy cheap alprazolam
purchase lasix online
buy valium
purchase diazepam online
buy cheap flagyl
price of accutane
discount cialis
price of acomplia
plavix
diazepam without prescription
purchase synthroid online
cheap flagyl online
buy bactrim cheap
purchase flagyl online
viagra for sale
diazepam generic
order phentermine
online accutane
buy generic viagra
buy cialis online
purchase soma
buy cheap viagra online
bactrim for sale
buy soma without prescription
purchase phentermine online
acomplia no prescription
accutane pills
zithromax online stores
buy plavix without prescription
zoloft cheap
soma for sale
generic zoloft
zithromax pills
cheap flagyl tablets
cheap doxycycline
cheap generic zithromax
discount bactrim
cheap bactrim online
order levitra online
cheap generic soma
pharmacy cialis
purchase valium
purchase flagyl
purchase diazepam
purchase acomplia
clomid cheap
cheapest zoloft
buy cheap bactrim
valium cheap
purchase prozac
diazepam discount
buy prozac
doxycycline pills
levitra prescription
buy cheap lasix
discount acomplia
viagra without prescription
xanax cheap
generic nexium
viagra without a prescription
cheap diazepam
cheapest bactrim prices
cheap bactrim tablets
cheap phentermine tablets
purchase lasix
cheap plavix
cheapest tramadol
discount doxycycline
buy lasix without prescription
lowest price xanax
cheap generic propecia
acomplia without a prescription
cheap accutane tablets
price of clomid
zithromax generic
buy zoloft
bactrim online stores
generic xanax
phentermine without a prescription
lowest price zoloft
cialis for sale
nexium without a prescription
buy generic soma
buy generic phentermine
clomid
pharmacy diazepam
buy cheap accutane online
cheapest lorazepam
tramadol cheap
buy cheap diazepam
cheap accutane
alprazolam for sale
synthroid online
order nexium online
cheap tramadol online
buy doxycycline without prescription
purchase levitra
buy phentermine cheap
buy alprazolam cheap
purchase tramadol online
bactrim
cheapest cialis
buy cheap lorazepam online
lorazepam pharmacy
zoloft online stores
flagyl
order diazepam
plavix cheap
order propecia
cheapest levitra
synthroid online cheap
clomid pills
accutane
cheap generic diazepam
valium without a prescription
xanax
cheap prozac online
soma sale
doxycycline prescription
online clomid
cheap soma online
plavix pills
order levitra
buy cheap acomplia online
cheap generic cialis
online lasix
order prozac
lorazepam online stores
zoloft
zoloft pills
buy zoloft online
order prozac online
plavix without a prescription
lorazepam pills
order synthroid online
buy soma
cialis
pharmacy lorazepam
diazepam sale
acomplia pharmacy
order bactrim online
buy valium online
lorazepam no prescription
alprazolam sale
buy lorazepam
accutane for sale
xanax without prescription
nexium online
buy lasix cheap
buy alprazolam
order accutane online
buy generic clomid
cheap acomplia online
valium pharmacy
cheap generic phentermine
purchase bactrim
buy zithromax without prescription
lowest price soma
acomplia sale
buy zithromax online
purchase tramadol
order clomid online
buy valium without prescription
alprazolam cheap
buy bactrim online
discount tramadol
cheapest xanax
buy clomid online
buy cheap doxycycline online
buy cheap valium
buy cheap accutane
generic bactrim
buy cheap prozac
cheap zoloft
where to buy nexium
zithromax cheap
propecia pharmacy
online propecia
buy diazepam
cialis without prescription
cialis discount
alprazolam online cheap
lowest price valium
cheap soma
acomplia online stores
bactrim online
buy cheap tramadol online
buy generic alprazolam
cheap levitra online
zoloft pharmacy
price of plavix
where to buy acomplia
generic levitra
discount flagyl
lorazepam discount
pharmacy lasix
cheap generic prozac
cheapest clomid prices
buy generic nexium
alprazolam prescription
order alprazolam
purchase plavix online
cheap soma tablets
cheap generic nexium
flagyl prescription
cheap xanax tablets
valium
purchase prozac online
order doxycycline online
discount levitra
pharmacy flagyl
lowest price alprazolam
synthroid without prescription
viagra sale
purchase plavix
xanax online
buy generic xanax
synthroid discount
order xanax
pharmacy levitra
levitra no prescription
doxycycline online stores
plavix prices
clomid pharmacy
where to buy bactrim
where to buy lasix
cheap valium online
pharmacy synthroid
flagyl online cheap
price of soma
order xanax online
cheap propecia online
cheap levitra
generic accutane
lorazepam
alprazolam
lorazepam prices
online plavix
buy cheap phentermine online
prozac
xanax online cheap
propecia without prescription
buy tramadol cheap
lasix pharmacy
cheapest prozac
order acomplia online
zithromax prescription
buy cheap synthroid online
propecia for sale
accutane prescription
buy cheap bactrim online
viagra generic
buy cheap viagra
lasix no prescription
buy levitra cheap
soma online cheap
bactrim generic
cheapest alprazolam
purchase lorazepam online
purchase xanax online
viagra pills
buy propecia online
online cialis
accutane pharmacy
cheap bactrim
phentermine generic
levitra online stores
lasix pills
purchase valium online
cheap generic plavix
lowest price synthroid
cheap viagra online
cheapest flagyl
synthroid sale
phentermine online cheap
online alprazolam
cheap doxycycline tablets
buy cheap nexium
purchase nexium
synthroid
purchase alprazolam
buy cheap xanax
cheapest clomid
cheapest nexium prices
cheap zithromax tablets
lowest price viagra
purchase bactrim online
phentermine prices
lowest price zithromax
discount lasix
flagyl pills
buy soma cheap
cheap lasix
buy soma online
buy phentermine
alprazolam generic
order cialis
accutane no prescription
cialis pills
price of nexium
doxycycline
buy cheap doxycycline
doxycycline sale
pharmacy alprazolam
buy generic prozac
viagra prices
bactrim sale
where to buy accutane
tramadol no prescription
nexium prescription
propecia no prescription
cialis prices
lasix without prescription
generic zithromax
purchase zithromax online
phentermine discount
cialis pharmacy
price of viagra
buy clomid
cialis cheap
cheapest synthroid prices
cheapest acomplia
purchase cialis
cheap generic levitra
lasix online
where to buy soma
valium prices
viagra prescription
cheapest zithromax prices
generic soma
buy lasix
xanax pills
pharmacy doxycycline
buy valium cheap
price of prozac
cheapest accutane prices
discount phentermine
generic alprazolam
zithromax pharmacy
buy cheap lasix online
buy plavix online
buy doxycycline online
accutane online stores
cialis online cheap
zithromax prices
synthroid without a prescription
zithromax no prescription
purchase clomid
buy cheap plavix
accutane discount
tramadol discount
acomplia online
soma cheap
pharmacy acomplia
pharmacy soma
buy flagyl
diazepam for sale
cheapest accutane
lowest price phentermine
diazepam no prescription
buy accutane online
tramadol pills
buy cheap synthroid
lowest price nexium
online nexium
alprazolam without a prescription
online zithromax
zithromax online cheap
online lorazepam
order soma
discount diazepam
cheapest doxycycline prices
price of lasix
discount lorazepam
lasix online stores
buy cheap propecia online
order bactrim
generic diazepam
buy phentermine online
buy phentermine without prescription
zoloft online
accutane online
accutane without a prescription
cheap tramadol tablets
nexium for sale
phentermine online
purchase xanax
clomid generic
propecia online cheap
phentermine without prescription
cheapest viagra prices
buy cheap propecia
clomid prescription
cheapest phentermine prices
soma no prescription
flagyl sale
order cialis online
cheap zithromax
viagra pharmacy
cheap zoloft tablets
lasix prices
flagyl for sale
online valium
nexium prices
lowest price levitra
purchase levitra online
clomid discount
lasix for sale
buy cheap prozac online
cheap alprazolam tablets
price of synthroid
cheap synthroid online
propecia sale
phentermine online stores
alprazolam online
diazepam prescription
tramadol without a prescription
zoloft prices
order alprazolam online
cheap lasix tablets
cheapest xanax prices
price of xanax
clomid without prescription
flagyl discount
levitra pharmacy
purchase soma online
tramadol for sale
cheapest lasix
cheap accutane online
buy synthroid online
pharmacy zithromax
nexium sale
buy generic lasix
nexium cheap
buy tramadol online
bactrim discount
zoloft without a prescription
cheap synthroid tablets
diazepam prices
buy cheap nexium online
online zoloft
buy cheap diazepam online
purchase phentermine
accutane without prescription
zithromax for sale
order viagra
pharmacy accutane
zithromax sale
buy cheap cialis
buy lasix online
cialis online stores
order nexium
diazepam online cheap
lorazepam without prescription
purchase zithromax
cheapest acomplia prices
zoloft no prescription
purchase doxycycline
order clomid
plavix online stores
zithromax
cialis generic
tramadol online
cheap lorazepam tablets
soma pharmacy
online flagyl
price of valium
pharmacy plavix
price of zoloft
order soma online
valium no prescription
online acomplia
viagra online stores
buy accutane cheap
buy cheap alprazolam online
cheap flagyl
prozac generic
purchase accutane
lowest price tramadol
buy cheap levitra online
prozac sale
bactrim pharmacy
flagyl online stores
buy nexium
generic lasix
purchase zoloft
cheap prozac
acomplia generic
cheapest zoloft prices
purchase viagra
levitra sale
buy generic valium
online phentermine
cheap viagra
where to buy zithromax
lasix generic
price of lorazepam
order phentermine online
lowest price plavix
bactrim prices
discount soma
doxycycline for sale
prozac without prescription
diazepam
viagra
levitra online cheap
cheap zithromax online
prozac discount
where to buy diazepam
lowest price doxycycline
nexium generic
zoloft without prescription
xanax prices
cheap valium tablets
cheap generic acomplia
order synthroid
phentermine pills
bactrim pills
discount viagra
buy cheap zithromax online
levitra without a prescription
purchase cialis online
buy bactrim without prescription
valium online cheap
lorazepam for sale
plavix discount
buy tramadol
online xanax
phentermine for sale
buy cheap phentermine
buy xanax cheap
lorazepam generic
buy flagyl without prescription
buy xanax online
where to buy cialis
alprazolam pharmacy
flagyl prices
propecia prices
buy nexium cheap
cheap synthroid
cheapest synthroid
soma without prescription
buy acomplia without prescription
doxycycline online
buy prozac without prescription
lowest price prozac
cheap viagra tablets
order flagyl online
zithromax without prescription
pharmacy bactrim
order viagra online
purchase viagra online
clomid online cheap
price of tramadol
alprazolam no prescription
discount clomid
generic lorazepam
buy cheap lorazepam
online viagra
cheap generic valium
generic synthroid
nexium no prescription
levitra generic
prozac without a prescription
diazepam without a prescription
buy cheap soma
purchase nexium online
cheap generic lasix
order lasix
clomid no prescription
acomplia
cheap clomid tablets
lasix discount
soma online stores
acomplia online cheap
cheapest flagyl prices
price of propecia
levitra prices
where to buy viagra
order zoloft
propecia discount
cheap generic alprazolam
phentermine cheap
clomid online
lorazepam online
buy doxycycline
buy viagra online
tramadol sale
lorazepam cheap
xanax without a prescription
tramadol pharmacy
purchase doxycycline online
flagyl pharmacy
lowest price clomid
cheap plavix tablets
soma without a prescription
viagra online cheap
alprazolam prices
synthroid online stores
buy zithromax cheap
buy generic acomplia
acomplia pills
order flagyl
cheap generic bactrim
where to buy propecia
diazepam pharmacy
synthroid pharmacy
flagyl without prescription
synthroid no prescription
discount zoloft
lasix sale
buy generic zoloft
diazepam pills
buy cheap zithromax
synthroid generic
phentermine sale
doxycycline without a prescription
price of zithromax
accutane cheap
purchase clomid online
buy cheap zoloft online
clomid online stores
order valium
flagyl generic
buy lorazepam online
buy levitra without prescription
tramadol online stores
plavix sale
buy viagra cheap
purchase lorazepam
diazepam online stores
cheap lasix online
order tramadol
propecia without a prescription
levitra cheap
propecia online stores
cheap valium
tramadol online cheap
cheapest valium
tramadol prescription
order lorazepam
cheapest cialis prices
generic cialis
cheapest tramadol prices
buy flagyl cheap
accutane sale
buy cheap valium online
pharmacy clomid
synthroid for sale
buy generic synthroid
order zoloft online
buy tramadol without prescription
synthroid cheap
cheap generic synthroid
clomid sale
prozac pills
buy propecia cheap
buy lorazepam cheap
where to buy plavix
order zithromax online
acomplia without prescription
buy diazepam cheap
buy diazepam without prescription
phentermine
zithromax without a prescription
price of doxycycline
cheap diazepam online
cheap xanax online
accutane online cheap
bactrim prescription
lowest price diazepam
prozac prices
levitra
propecia online
cheap phentermine online
soma
order propecia online
generic prozac
valium online
discount xanax
cheapest diazepam
where to buy xanax
discount alprazolam
cheap acomplia
order valium online
buy viagra without prescription
cheapest phentermine
cheapest alprazolam prices
xanax discount
order lasix online
pharmacy propecia
zoloft online cheap
buy bactrim
plavix prescription
online synthroid
generic clomid
generic flagyl
buy levitra
cheapest prozac prices
clomid for sale
price of alprazolam
buy synthroid
buy cheap xanax online
doxycycline without prescription
buy levitra online
plavix no prescription
viagra no prescription
buy diazepam online
buy cheap clomid
prozac online cheap
alprazolam pills
propecia prescription
nexium online cheap
buy accutane
zoloft sale
cheap acomplia tablets
cialis without a prescription
order tramadol online
nexium discount
cheapest propecia
where to buy doxycycline
synthroid pills
tramadol
discount propecia
plavix online cheap
cheap propecia
viagra online
buy clomid without prescription
clomid prices
zoloft generic
clomid without a prescription
plavix without prescription
cheap nexium tablets
doxycycline online cheap
cheap generic clomid
generic doxycycline
where to buy zoloft
buy cheap soma online
where to buy clomid
buy doxycycline cheap
buy cheap levitra
cheap generic xanax
price of cialis
cialis prescription
buy clomid cheap
pharmacy xanax
prozac no prescription
levitra for sale
doxycycline discount
viagra cheap
cheapest plavix
buy synthroid without prescription
cheap nexium
pharmacy phentermine
bactrim online cheap
doxycycline pharmacy
buy cheap flagyl online
nexium
purchase synthroid
zithromax discount
buy prozac cheap
cheapest viagra
buy cialis
discount nexium
cheap generic accutane
price of flagyl
generic viagra
lasix without a prescription
zoloft prescription
bactrim without prescription
valium prescription
where to buy valium
levitra without prescription
cheap generic tramadol
acomplia prescription
buy cheap zoloft
prozac prescription
cheap prozac tablets
price of bactrim
diazepam online
cheapest soma prices
nexium pharmacy
generic acomplia
viagra discount
order acomplia
lorazepam online cheap
purchase propecia
xanax for sale
lowest price propecia
where to buy synthroid
cheap zoloft online
generic propecia
propecia generic
doxycycline prices
levitra pills
price of levitra
cheapest propecia prices
buy generic flagyl
flagyl cheap
soma pills
lowest price accutane
buy zithromax
valium sale
lowest price lorazepam
buy cialis without prescription
cheap propecia tablets
tramadol generic
phentermine no prescription
generic phentermine
buy generic levitra
plavix for sale
buy generic plavix
tramadol without prescription
buy nexium online
doxycycline generic
acomplia prices
order zithromax
buy xanax
prozac cheap
nexium online stores
buy alprazolam without prescription
cialis sale
lasix prescription
soma online
cheap generic lorazepam
buy flagyl online
valium without prescription
where to buy tramadol
price of phentermine
diazepam cheap
cheapest bactrim
zoloft for sale
buy cheap plavix online
doxycycline no prescription
xanax online stores
cheap lorazepam online
purchase acomplia online
cheapest nexium
acomplia discount
buy synthroid cheap
generic plavix
cheapest soma
valium discount
discount plavix
nexium pills
bactrim without a prescription
generic valium
cheap doxycycline online
buy plavix cheap
phentermine prescription
buy generic bactrim
soma generic
cheap xanax
pharmacy viagra
buy alprazolam online
cheap cialis tablets
buy cheap tramadol
lorazepam prescription
accutane prices
buy generic doxycycline
buy generic propecia
acomplia cheap
cheap generic flagyl
plavix generic
where to buy phentermine
accutane generic
order plavix online
cheapest lasix prices
buy generic tramadol
buy nexium without prescription
flagyl online
online doxycycline
xanax no prescription
buy zoloft without prescription
lowest price lasix
buy acomplia online
buy generic accutane
buy xanax without prescription
alprazolam discount
online prozac
On July 6, 2006, Colorado federal appeals court judge Richard P. Matsch ruled that companies such as Cleanfilms, Cleanflicks, and similar companies violate copyright laws by editing Hollywood’s movies.
To read the judge’s full opinion, click here.
Your thoughts?
August 2nd, 2006 at 11:30 am
The court ruling here is totally unconstitutional. In no way are these companies creating “derivative works” or breaking copyright law. These companies buy original DVD’s, destroy their data side so it can’t be read, and include the edited version with the original.
Derivative works are like me making a film about Obi-Wan Kenobi running around in Middle Earth, it is a new story based off another that I claim to be mine and make a profit from. The edited movies keep the same plot and movie except for the getting rid of the trash!
The solution to this problem. The companies need to ignor the ruling since it is unconstitutional and breaks our right of free enterprise and possession of private property. Some of these services edit DVDs you already own, so they are within their constitutional rights since you own the DVD (private property that the government has no right to interfere with) and they edit it with their services (free enterprise that the government has no right to interfere with).
Judges don’t make law, so since he put these certain companies out of business others can start without any hassle because this ruling is not law. If the DGA and other want to totally eradicate this kind of service than legislation must be brought before congress and approved before these companies must really shut down. Even then the law would violate the constitution which (along with the Word of God) is supreme law in the land.
Ignore the judge! He has ruled falsely without ever hardely mentioning the Constitution, but instead other cases which are not law! If any ruling does not line up with the Constitution it must be ignored! The judge who ruled falsely should be told to correct his error or stand guilty of breaking the law of the land and stand impeachment for doing so!
Keep on editing these movies! You have the Constitutional right!
August 2nd, 2006 at 2:30 pm
I completey agree. The ruling the judge made is un-constitutional and should be ignored by these companies. Unfortunately, they have all shut down already. This ruling was a strike against families in this country.
August 2nd, 2006 at 5:54 pm
Is there any place where we can sign a petition against this ruling?
August 3rd, 2006 at 10:58 am
This is a actually a loss for Hollywood because they have lost a large consumer, who wants nothing more than to watch their movies without defiling innocent minds. Those of us, who were participating in the renting of these clean movies, were contributing to the financial hunger of Hollywood. Now both sides have lost and, for what? Gold star to you, Hollywood, for driving another nail into the coffin of family values and showing your true colors. There is no reason for this blatent need for control.
August 9th, 2006 at 6:19 pm
It is absolutely outrageous that we now have no right to choose NO GARBAGE. If these companies legitimately purchase the original copy of the movie, Hollywood should just SHUT UP!! No matter what, the movie studios do not have the right to demand that we watch junk.
The thought police are alive and well with this ruling - pray for this misguided judge.
August 10th, 2006 at 5:50 pm
You can not believe my disappointment when I saw what has happened with these companies that care enough to make clean movies that you are not worried about letting your children watch. A friend of mine told me about this site and I was so excited, I know when I tell her that “Judges” have decided that it is illegal she will also be disappointed and mad! I don’t understand what the deal is if they have leave the movies story intact and just take out the vulgar language and scenes who cares??? Are producers going to make a version that we would be proud to show in our homes for each vulgar version? I think not! Seems like our clean companies will not be buying any movies to clean up so there goes those producers sale rates.. surely it is a sad day for Christian Movie Watchers!
August 12th, 2006 at 11:16 am
Folks,
I understand a lot of people have been affected in a negative manner over this controversial courtroom decision, but there is a flip side to the coin. A famous website that advocates clean television broadcasting published an article that sums things up very well. The author of the article stated that he would not want someone to take one of his published articles, edit it in any way they deemed fit and re-publish it still bearing his name. Mind you, this is a person who writes the parenting column for this site and he is just as disgusted with Hollywood’s “filth” as many of you are. However, in this case, the ends do not justify the means.
Perhaps Hollywood, recognizing a market for “cleaned” movies, will start releasing their “airline” versions of films to the general public. This is the letter writing campaign that should be waged.
August 12th, 2006 at 11:29 am
Thanks for your comment, Chuck. I do see that there are two sides to every story, however, I think confusion arises over the terms we use. You mentioned the term “re-publish”. Certainly this author would have no qualms if a person printed out his article and chose to read every other line. Or maybe they took their printed copy and blacked out every appearance of the word “tomorrow”. Is this re-publishing? Of course not. OK, now what if instead of the individual making these marks himself, he asks his neighbor to do it, for he just doesn’t have the time or resources. The next day the neighbor knocks on the door and delivers the printed article, just as the man had asked. Are we re-publishing yet? Of course not. This neighbor has simply provided a service to the man. In essence, this is what was occuring. A service was being provided to consumers who owned a piece of material.
I think Hollywood has really done a good job of spinning this whole situation, claiming that these editing companies are confusing individuals in to believing that their copy of the movie is the original. Consider this quote from the DGA: “Audiences can now be assured that the films they buy or rent are the vision of the filmmakers who made them and not the arbitrary choices of a third-party editor.” Was anybody every confused over the matter!? No!!! This is classic spin from Hollywood!
Anyways…I think we need to make a distinction between re-publishing and providing a service.
August 12th, 2006 at 12:03 pm
Dear Sir/Ma’am,
I am enclosing a link to the article I mentioned above so that everyone can read his exact words.
Enjoy.
http://www.parentstv.org/PTC/publications/rgcolumns/2006/0713.asp
August 21st, 2006 at 4:05 pm
Hollywood I have a remote and I know how to use it.
The Seamless Branching feature in DVD’s is there to allow multiple versions of a movie to be shown.
So far all I have seen is this feature used to insert additional material. But it could easily be used to omit material.
Since many films are edited for content by the studios for foreign markets, Planes or television this should not be hard.
Recently I read an article stating that additional material was added to the movie “snakes on a Plane” to make it R rated rather then PG.
Unfortunately many movie tie-ins were already in place the result that my local science museums ran snake exhibits
Result Elementary school kids being targeted for a R rated movie. Tell me what’s so artistic about that.
August 23rd, 2006 at 3:54 pm
I like the remote idea would you people use it and shut up, this has to be one of greatest rulings in US history. BRVO Judge I have been waiting for this sense the day these Sensor all that I think is not good for me than it is not good for you stores opened.
August 24th, 2006 at 10:13 pm
Nice argument…
August 25th, 2006 at 5:24 am
When people purchase something, they are owner of the property (not the copyright owner). As owner the property, they can do what ever they want with it. If they choose to have their movies censored, that is their decision, NOT a federal judge, and definitely NOT hollywood. If they choose not to be subjected to the material through censoring themselves, they have a right to pay pay someone else to censor the movies for them. Government can not make laws regarding what you do in the privacy of your own home. Whether you choose to watch porno movies if you want, or you can choose to watch censored movies. The decision is up to the individual, NOT a federal judge. That judge is violating the law for attempting to take away people’s constitutional rights! Fortunately, there are still editing services still in existence (that were not mentioned in the lawsuit), who will continue their “service,” despite an unconstitional ruling.
August 26th, 2006 at 7:56 am
Um, you’re a little “shaky” on your knowlege of the laws there, Jessica. You may not do whatever you please with something simply because you own it. If I own a house, I can’t burn it down simply because I own it. Also, the government has been making laws on what you can and can’t do in the privacy of your home for quite some time now. Lastly, I don’t remember anything in the Constitution protecting the rights for re-distributing altered versions of copyrighted materials.
August 31st, 2006 at 1:19 am
First, if I own a house, I CAN burn it down as long as it is not affecting anyone else. If that house is in a neighborhood with other houses in close promixity, obviously it would affect many people. If that house is isolated on my own land in the middle of the desert, it has does not affect anyone.
Second, the government “tries” to make laws on what you can and can’t do in the privacy of your home. That does not make those laws constitutional. I recall Texas having an anti-homosexual law for many years where they could arrest people for practicing homosexuality, even in the privacy of their own home. I disagree with the practice of homosexuality, however the US Supreme Court ruled that the law was unconstitional.
Third, no one said anything about “re-distributing altered versions of copyrighted materials.” If I buy a wedding dress from one store and then go to another store and pay more money to have it altered. That is MY choice. It is for my own private use. You can not go through life without hiring a “service” that “alters” something at some point. When you remodel your house, that is changing the artistic view of the architect’s design, but it is your choice what to do with the house once you bought it. When you buy an SUV and take it to an auto body shop to get fancy grill bumpers put on, change the wheels, jack it up off the ground, and change the pant from a red to camoflauge …those are ALL things done to alter the original intent of the auto manufacturer. So, should the auto manufacture have a right to sue the auto body shop for performing a service for an individual who hired them??? Of course not. Quite simply, you need to sit down and shut up because you are missing the whole point of why people are willing to pay money for a service to edit movies so they can watch them without being subjected to things that violate their moral code of conduct.
August 31st, 2006 at 7:53 am
The government “tries” to make laws as to what you can do in the privacy of your own home? Can you smoke marijuana in the privacy of your home? Of course not (not legally, anyway).
And as to your analogy with the dress, sure you can alter it, just like you can your very own copy of a DVD. If you tried to “re-distribute” a bunch of altered dresses with that original designer’s name on them, you might find yourself with a lawsuit (rightfully) on your hands. That is exactly why a lot of moviemakers are so unhappy with these services; Their names are left on products that they did not edit.
But this is, quite simply, silly to argue about since there still exists plenty of ways and services for the legal (currently) editing of your movies which contain items that violate your “moral code”.
August 31st, 2006 at 6:02 pm
Chuck…again it seems there is a disconnect between providing a service and “re-distributing”. I brought this up on August 12 when you commented about re-publishing. I wonder how you define “re-publish” or “re-distribute”, and how one could arrive here from providing a service?
August 31st, 2006 at 6:45 pm
If a person buys a DVD, sends it to a service for “cleaning” and has it sent back, it is not re-distribution. However, when a company purchases the DVD (first retail distribution), cleans and sells it, that is the second distribution.
Hence, the word re-distribute.
August 31st, 2006 at 6:52 pm
OK, so if I want to buy James Bond and send it to you for editing, that’s cool? But what if I don’t own it yet? OK, I’ll go to the store and buy it, then send it to you. No problem. Wait…I can’t leave the house tonight, I’m watching my infant. Can you just buy it for me?
Would that be re-distribution?
August 31st, 2006 at 7:29 pm
Actually, I’m not stating which service I consider better or worse; I’m simply providing the definition (or example) of my use of the word re-distribute, that’s all.
By the way, did you follow the above link to the article (and if so, did you e-mail him)?
September 2nd, 2006 at 11:46 am
>However, when a company purchases the DVD (first retail distribution),
>cleans and sells it, that is the second distribution.
>Hence, the word re-distribute.
So based on your definition of distribution, there are THOUSANDS of companies across the US at risk of “re-distributing” DVDs. Example: When Blockbuster purchases the DVD (first retail distribution) and then sells it, that is the second distribution….according to YOUR definition. Obviously, you don’t have a rat’s clue what “re-distribute” REALLY means!
September 4th, 2006 at 6:45 pm
Yes, and I guess you don’t have much understanding as to what consent from the studios means. Really, why should you let the facts get in the way when you can throw out one non sequitur after another (analogically anyway) and try to make silly tabloidlike points with the use of caitalising (REALLY) and exclamation points at the end of sentences.
Oh, and those movies that are being re-distributed by Blockbuster have not been altered, so stick to the point and try to remain coherent in your babble ridden debates.
September 5th, 2006 at 10:07 pm
I suggest that we go to hometheaterforum.com and voice our opinions. The bigwigs in Hollywood frequent that site often getting opinions of other users. We should let them know we will not buy their products unless we can have them the way we want: Without the vulgar filth!
September 16th, 2006 at 2:03 pm
These movies in their edited version were one of the prime together-times for our family. We enjoyed each visit to rent them, and were enriched as we watched wholesomely and happily. There is nothing noble in trampling that which is sweet and good for families, in favor of trying to force us to either not view almost all of Hollywood’s offerings or fill our minds and homes with garbage.
I hope that Constitutional values will somehow be brought to light again, and that our rights as citizens will be retored.
May 4th, 2007 at 9:03 pm
I am so glad that someone has developed the technology needed to protect my rights to not listen garbage and still enjoy the movies.